If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, STYLECASTER may receive an affiliate commission.

Though everyone is talking about Y2K these days, ’90s makeup will always be in style. Anyone who wears it — with its smudgy black eyeliner and brown-ish lipstick — feels like the coolest person in the room. And you don’t have to spend a lot to nail the look. Just ask Sabrina Carpenter. At the Billboard Women in Music Awards Wednesday night, the singer hit the red carpet with a natural-looking face and a cool ’90s lip — which costs less than $6 to recreate. For real.

Makeup artist Allan Avendano created a chestnut lip for Carpenter with Hard Candy’s new Insta Pout Lip Liner in Boyfriend ($5.97 at Walmart). According to the brand, he blended it in with a finger to create the chestnut-colored just-kissed look. You don’t even need a real lipstick to slay the same exact look.

This new liner is vegan and cruelty-free, smudge-proof (once it dries down) and non-drying. It comes in six shades, all of which costs less than $6. We can’t believe it either.

hard candy liner

Hard Candy.

Avendano used some other staple Hard Candy products for the singer’s look, including the Sheer Envy Luminous Serum Glow Primer ($8.94 at Walmart), Face Off Luminous Liquid Blush in Who Is She ($7.94 at Walmart) and Face Off Highlighter Stick in Champagne Breakfast ($7.94 at Walmart). For her eyes, he used Eye Def Eyeshadow Markers ($5.97 at Walmart) in Stoned on the outer corners and Bubbly in the inner corners of her eyes to “brighten and create a pulled up, lifted eye shape,” according to the brand. He finished her eyes with Sheer Envy Glow Primer ($8.94 at Walmart) on her eyelids for even more glow.

Scott King was on hair and Zola Ganzorigt was on nails. The results of all these talented people’s hard work? Absolutely stunning.

StyleCaster Shopping Newsletter Sign Up